Deciding on a Rubber Mulch vs. Wood Mulch Playground

Researching mulch materials is an essential consideration in playground design, whether it's for a school, daycare center, park, home playground, or another space. A quick search reveals that many people often question whether rubber mulch is superior to wood mulch. Understanding the unique features of these options will help you make an informed choice tailored to your needs. 

With competitive pricing and prompt delivery, Optima hopes to be your supplier and partner.

Is Rubber Mulch Better than Wood Mulch?

The Best Wood Mulch Available

Engineered wood fibers (EWF) mulch is created from the soft pulpy interior of the wood, making it a less abrasive option than conventional wood mulch that contains bark. This characteristic makes it an excellent choice for playgrounds and various outdoor surfaces. 

Cost of Rubber Mulch vs. Wood Mulch 

EWF mulch, being organic, is an affordable and readily available resource, especially when compared to synthetic materials like rubber mulch. Products such as PIP rubber mulch and crumb rubber mulch come with a higher initial cost due to the complex processes involved in rubber production, whether the material is brand new or recycled. 

Environmental Impact 

Rubber, as an artificial material, can take decades to decompose, leading to environmental concerns. Although recycled rubber mulch is a more ecologically friendly option compared to new rubber, it still does not blend well with the natural environment. Residual rubber bits may remain long after a playground has been taken down, and the removal of rubber mulch requires professional intervention to ensure all particles are cleared.

Moreover, rubber mulch is primarily made from old tires, which may contain pollutants, posing risks to soil integrity and plant life. EWF mulch, however, integrates well with its surroundings, enriching the soil over time as it decomposes and enhancing soil quality, which benefits nearby vegetation by retaining moisture and improving soil structure. It also helps reduce flooding by absorbing rainwater. 

Longevity

Although rubber mulch can last for 20 years or more, the inability to decompose naturally signifies its disruptive nature to ecosystems. Wood mulch typically has a shorter lifespan but breaks down at a reasonable pace, with maintenance influencing its longevity. 

Appearance

For some, the visual aspect of playground mulch is crucial. Rubber mulch offers a variety of artificial colors while EWF mulch features a natural brown hue that harmonizes with the environment.

Maintenance

EWF mulch requires replenishing every few years, potentially annually. Conversely, rubber mulch generally demands little to no significant upkeep unless it’s damaged or becomes moldy. However, mulch is regarded as a low-maintenance ground covering overall. 

Safety

Safety is paramount, especially regarding children. Recycled rubber mulch can release volatile organic compounds (VOCs), which are intensified by warm temperatures, potentially causing health issues ranging from nausea to more severe conditions. In contrast, wood mulch is a safer choice, cushioning falls effectively without releasing harmful chemicals. EWF mulch provides greater protection against falls compared to sand or gravel. 

EWF Mulch Installation Process

Get a Free Quote

For a free estimate on your project, don't hesitate to get in touch with our team at Superior Groundcover. We’re here to answer any questions regarding EWF playground mulch and its maintenance. 

Choose Your Mulch Material

We provide options for both new and recycled EWF mulch, giving you the flexibility to select the best fit for your playground. 

Enjoy One-Day Installation

Thanks to our specialized Express Blower® trucks, we can install playground mulch efficiently, allowing children to return to playing within the same day, minimizing disruption. 

Superior Groundcover&#;s EWF Playground Mulch Installation

When deciding between rubber and wood mulch for playgrounds, the clear choice is evident. EWF mulch stands out as a beneficial wood mulch option despite rubber's longevity and colorful appearance. It contributes positively to environmental health and child safety, providing cushioning against falls while maintaining a neat, inviting play space. Reach out for quick EWF mulch installation services today.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can You Mix Rubber Mulch with Wood Mulch?

When deliberating between rubber and wood mulch for playgrounds, consider mixing the two. Applying a layer of EWF mulch on top of rubber mulch can help regulate temperatures and reduce VOC emissions. 

For more rubber mulch machine information, please reach out to us for expert guidance.

Is Rubber Mulch a Fire Hazard?

Rubber mulch can pose a fire risk. Tests by Consumer Reports have shown that rubber mulch burns more rapidly and is more challenging to extinguish than wood mulch, primarily due to the petroleum byproducts contained within it.

How Are Rubber Mulch and EWF Playground Mulch Made?

EWF mulch is derived from the soft fibers within trees, excluding the bark, offering superior cushioning. Rubber mulch, often made from shredded tires following metal removal, is then dyed for appearance. Other rubber products can also contribute to rubber mulch creation.