PCB Surface Finish Types & Comparison | Pros & Cons
PCB Surface Finish Types & Comparison | Pros & Cons
ENEPIG
Electroless nickel electroless palladium immersion gold (ENEPIG) is another alternative for the surface coating of a PCB &#; it uses multiple layers to create a universal finish that can work with numerous applications, such as soldering or wire bonding with gold, aluminum and copper. ENEPIG is one of the more optimum choices for wire bonding as well as most PCB applications.
If you want to learn more, please visit our website CHANYEE.
The order of the layers over the substrate corresponds to the name of this surface finish. Over a copper base is an electroless nickel layer. Atop that layer goes an electroless palladium coating. The palladium prevents the nickel from passing through to the gold layer on top. The final coating, an immersion gold layer, keeps the palladium from interacting with environmental contaminants that could otherwise impede soldering.
ENEPIG printed circuit boards were popular many years ago due to their overall board support and are now rising once again thanks to a significant decrease in the cost of palladium. The design has been shown to successfully operate in conjunction with lead-free and eutectic solder alloys as well as most assembly processes.
ENEPIG vs. Other Finishes
ENEPIG is often referred to as a &#;universal&#; finish because it can be used for almost any PCB and in all assembly processes. Palladium completely dissolves during soldering so there is no oxide present in the nickel surface. This means your application has less probability of errors, and you can safely use it with varying solder applications.
Compared to other finishes, ENEPIG printed circuit boards will have a greater solder joint strength and are more likely to meet your industry requirements for overall PCB life and durability.
The advantages and disadvantages of ENEPIG are:
Advantages: The gold surface layer protects the PCB from tarnish and corrosion. The use of multiple layers inhibits corrosion from metal diffusion. Additionally, the composition of this finish provides a lead-free surface with a high solder strength while offering a more cost-effective option compared to electroless gold or electrolytic nickel gold. Lower contact resistance &#; The electrical resistance of this finish is uniform due to its production process and creates a situation where amperage is easier to predict and manage. Other advantages include:
- Pore-free finish.
- Significantly higher bond pull strength. High pull weights are maintained through multiple tests, making it especially suited to gold ball and aluminum wedge bonding.
- Strong solderability thanks to nickel protecting and reducing copper dissolution.
- Supports conductive adhesives for applications that do not need or may be harmed by solder.
- Won&#;t tarnish, extending its useful life.
And perhaps the best news of all is that the ENEPIG process tends to provide significant savings over electrolytic nickel gold and electroless nickel or electroless gold.
Disadvantage: Due to the inclusion of palladium and gold, both precious metals, this surface finish may not be as cost-effective as options that do not use these materials. Additionally, the application of the multiple layers must follow careful procedures for success and good solderability.
Call 717-558-
Top 10 PCB Surface Finishes: Pros, Cons, and Comparisons
Introduction
PCB surface finishes include two major categories: organic and metallic.
When comparing these two categories and considering all available options, it becomes clear that each has its benefits and drawbacks.
The choice of the most suitable finish is typically determined by factors such as the intended application, the assembly process, and the PCB design itself.
If you&#;re unsure about the most appropriate surface finish for your project, it&#;s advisable to consult with MorePCB before making a final decision. Our expertise will ensure that the chosen combination of surface finish and material yields a cost-effective design with optimal performance.
This article will help readers to have a brief understanding of PCB surfaces, their types use cases, etc.
What is PCB Surface Finish?
A printed circuit board&#;s (PCB) copper traces and pads receive a final coating or treatment known as a PCB surface finish. It is a crucial stage in the manufacture of PCBs and serves a variety of functions, including protection, solderability, and general reliability.
To avoid oxidation, which can impair the PCB&#;s electrical conductivity and solderability, the surface finish is applied to the exposed copper surfaces. Between the copper and the environment, it serves as a barrier. As a result, it guards against corrosion and guarantees the PCB&#;s long-term functioning.
Additionally, the surface finish plays a crucial role in facilitating soldering during the assembly process. It provides a flat, solderable surface on the copper pads, by enabling the secure attachment of electronic components to the PCB. The choice of surface finish affects the wetting and adhesion properties of the solder. Therefore it impacts the quality of solder joints and the overall reliability of the PCB assembly.
There are several types of surface finishes commonly used in PCB manufacturing. These include Hot Air Solder Leveling (HASL), Electroless Nickel Immersion Gold (ENIG), Organic Solderability Preservative (OSP), Immersion Tin, and Immersion Silver. Each surface finish has its advantages, limitations, and suitability for specific applications.
The selection of the appropriate surface finish depends on various factors, including the desired electrical performance, budget, assembly processes, component types, and environmental conditions. Manufacturers carefully consider these factors to ensure the best possible surface finish is chosen to meet the specific requirements of the PCB design.
The Importance of Choosing the Right PCB Surface Finishes
Protection Against Oxidation
Selecting the correct Printed Circuit Board (PCB) surface finish is crucial. It&#;s not just aesthetics; it&#;s about practicality. Most importantly, the right finish shields your PCB against oxidation. Picture this: the critical copper traces on your board are exposed, and unprotected. Oxidation creeps in, compromising functionality. It&#;s grim, isn&#;t it? That&#;s where a surface finish steps in. Acting as a barrier, it wards off oxidation, enhancing your board&#;s lifespan. Your PCB, armored and robust, can now face harsh environments. Every PCB deserves such protection, and the correct surface finish offers precisely that.
Enhancing Solderability
Transitioning to another significant facet, enhancing solderability. Let&#;s decode this. A PCB without a surface finish is like a car without fuel; it&#;s not going anywhere. Surface finishes boost solderability, making your PCB more conductive. It&#;s simple: the better the solderability, the better the electronic connections. The result? A high-performing PCB. Plus, it&#;s a blessing for assemblers, making their job easy, and smooth. So, choose the right surface finish, enhance your PCB&#;s solderability, and gear up for unmatched performance.
Prolonging Shelf Life
Lastly, the right surface finish prolongs your PCB&#;s shelf life. Think of it as a protective layer. This layer safeguards your PCB against wear and tear, maintaining its integrity. The result? Your PCB stays fresh, and usable, even after sitting on the shelf for a long. The importance of this cannot be overstressed. Why? Because a longer shelf life equals lesser wastage, saving you time, money, and resources. So, don&#;t just settle for any finish. Choose the right one. Your PCB deserves a long, healthy life. Let the correct surface finish make that happen.
Types of PCB Surface Finishes
1. Hot Air Solder Leveling (HASL)
In the vast expanse of the electronics manufacturing industry, PCB surface finishes hold an essential role. They provide a solderable surface for component assembly while protecting the copper from oxidation. Among these surface finishes, Hot Air Solder Leveling (HASL) stands as one of the most common and efficient choices. This type of surface finish applies a molten tin-lead coating to a PCB via hot air knives. Let&#;s dive into the specifics of HASL, including its advantages, disadvantages, and common applications.
Pros
Cost-effective: HASL is among the least expensive surface finishes.
Widespread availability: Due to its popularity, HASL services are easy to find.
Reworkable: Mistakes can be corrected and revised.
Cons
Lead usage: For some applications, the use of lead might be restricted due to environmental regulations.
Uneven surfaces: The application of HASL may result in uneven surfaces, problematic for smaller components.
Thermal shock: PCBs, especially thinner ones, might suffer from thermal shock during the HASL process.
Use Cases
General Electronics: HASL is suitable for general-purpose electronics where cost-effectiveness is vital.
Prototyping: Its ease of rework makes HASL a perfect choice for prototypes, where changes are often needed.
Non-fine pitch applications: HASL is suitable where surface planarity isn&#;t as critical, such as non-fine pitch applications.
2. Immersion Tin
Immersion Tin, also known as immersion tin plating or white tin, is a surface finish used in printed circuit boards (PCBs). It involves immersing the PCB in a chemical bath containing tin compounds, resulting in the deposition of a thin layer of tin onto the exposed copper surfaces. The immersion tin process is typically performed after undergoing PCB fabrication and before solder mask application.
Pros
Excellent solderability: Immersion tin provides a flat, uniform surface that enables excellent solderability, particularly for fine-pitch components.
Cost-effective: Immersion tin is generally more affordable compared to other surface finishes like ENIG or Immersion Silver.
Suitable for multiple reflows: Immersion tin can withstand multiple reflow soldering processes without significant degradation.
Cons
Shelf life and storage conditions: Immersion tin has a limited shelf life compared to some other surface finishes. It is sensitive to oxidation, and if not stored properly, the tin layer can oxidize, affecting solderability.
Reliability concerns: The immersion tin is not as durable as some other finishes.
Use Cases
Immersion tin is widely used in various applications, including:
Consumer electronics: It is commonly found in devices such as smartphones, tablets, and home appliances, where cost-effectiveness and fine-pitch component solderability are crucial.
Communication equipment: The immersion tin is suitable for applications in telecommunications devices, routers, network switches, and other communication equipment.
Automotive electronics: Certain automotive PCBs utilize immersion tin due to its cost-effectiveness and compatibility with reflow processes.
Industrial and medical electronics: Immersion tin finds application in industrial control systems, medical devices, and equipment where reliable solderability is essential.
3. Immersion Silver
Immersion tin is an eco-friendly surface finish for PCBs that applies a thin tin layer to copper pads. Known for its uniform, flat surface, it&#;s well-suited for fine-pitch components and diverse assembly processes, such as surface mount technology. The process requires dipping the PCB into a tin salt solution, which reacts with the copper surface, forming a protective layer against oxidation and ensuring solderability.
Its compatibility with lead-free soldering and resistance to high temperatures make it a preferred choice. Besides, the uniform tin surface enhances accuracy in component placement, reducing defects. Immersion tin also strengthens solder joints due to the formation of intermetallic compounds with copper, thereby improving the PCB&#;s overall reliability.
Pros
Flat surfaces are ideal for fine-pitch components, boosting assembly yields.
Provides a robust and reliable solder joint.
Offers middle-ground longevity compared to other finishes.
Cons
Tin whiskers can develop, causing potential short circuits.
Limited shelf life as oxidation occurs after a period.
Not suitable for multiple reflow or assembly processes.
Use Cases
This is mainly applied in the automotive industry due to its robustness.
Used in telecommunication devices where fine pitch components are involved.
Appropriate for products requiring medium-term protection from oxidation.
4. Electroless Nickel Immersion Gold (ENIG)
The exploration of electroless nickel immersion gold (ENIG) takes us deep into the heart of PCB finishing. A marvel of modern technology, ENIG is a technique that gives us reliable, top-quality circuit boards. Without the use of an electric current, a nickel layer is plated on the PCB, followed by a thin coating of gold. It&#;s a chemical reaction that plays out like an elegant ballet, ensuring precision and perfection.
Pros
Superior Contact Resistance: ENIG promises excellent contact resistance, paving the way for smooth electronic flow.
Robust Shelf Life: Its durability ensures a long shelf life, standing strong against the test of time.
Ideal for PTH: The process is perfect for Plated Through Hole (PTH) technology.
Cons
High Cost: The high quality comes with a price tag, making it an expensive choice.
Black Pad Syndrome: This is a risk. It&#;s an uninvited guest that can cause a barrier in the connection between the gold and the nickel.
Complex Process: It&#;s not a simple task. It requires strict control over the processing conditions.
Use Cases
High-Density Interconnects ( HDI ): ENIG is the star of the HDI show, being commonly used due to its reliability.
Fine Pitch Assemblies: With its good coplanarity, it is often chosen for fine pitch assemblies.
Wire Bonding: In the field of wire bonding, the ENIG process makes its mark due to the gold&#;s intrinsic properties.
5. Electroless Nickel Electroless Palladium Immersion Gold (ENEPIG)
Electroless Nickel Electroless Palladium Immersion Gold (ENEPIG) stands as a three-layer coating applied on printed circuit boards (PCBs). An initial nickel layer to create a barrier, a palladium layer to aid wire bonding, and finally, an immersion gold layer for solderability.
Pros
ENEPIG provides a universal surface finish, compatible with almost all types of assembly processes.
It offers superior wire bonding and soldering capabilities.
It has an excellent shelf-life and does not tarnish easily.
ENEPIG is lead-free, making it an environmentally friendly choice.
Cons
It is costlier than most other surface finishes due to its multi-layered process.
The complex process requires skilled technicians and specialized machinery.
The gold layer is extremely thin, making it susceptible to wear.
Use Cases
It is widely used in the manufacture of complex PCBs where multiple assembly processes are involved.
High-reliability applications like aerospace, medical, and military extensively use ENEPIG.
In the realm of electronics manufacturing services (EMS), ENEPIG finds use due to its lead-free nature.
6. Organic Solderability Preservatives (OSP)
Emerging as a silent game-changer in the electronics industry, Organic Solderability Preservatives, abbreviated as OSP. They&#;re thin layers applied to bare copper for preserving solderability. Simplifying assembly processes, they offer an economical solution. Yet, they also invite a set of challenges. This write-up will delve into the ins and outs of OSP.
Pros
Economical: Cost-effectiveness is a standout trait. OSP coats are less expensive than traditional methods.
Simplified Assembly Process: OSP involves a simpler, smoother assembly process compared to other surface finishes.
Flat Surfaces: OSP provides flatter surfaces for superior electrical performance.
Cons
Limited Shelf Life: OSP layers have a shorter shelf life, demanding rigorous inventory control.
Limited Handling: OSP-coated PCBs can&#;t withstand multiple reflows and extensive handling.
If you want to learn more, please visit our website pcb surface finish comparison.
Less Visual Inspection : It&#;s tough to ascertain the quality of OSP visually, leading to potential quality issues.
Use Cases
High-Speed Circuit Boards: OSP&#;s flat surfaces make them an ideal choice for high-speed circuit boards.
Fine-Pitch Technology: OSP coats are suitable for advanced technology like fine-pitch components due to their thinness.
Surface Mount Assemblies: OSP is commonly used in surface mount assemblies where clean, flat surfaces are crucial.
7. Hard Gold Plating
The hard gold plating technique crafts a fine, grainy surface, and tougher layers by blending gold with another element, such as iron, nickel, or cobalt. Like above Gold fingers PCB.
Pros
Unyielding Durability: Hard gold stands tall against the onslaught of time. It laughs in the face of corrosion and tarnish. Its high wear resistance offers years of service, making it a reliable ally.
Excellent Conductivity: The golden conductor ensures your electrical signals take the most efficient route. A dependable steed, galloping through the circuits without a falter.
Smooth Surface: The silky landscape of hard gold eliminates friction. Connectors slide home with elegant ease, ballroom dance in an electronic world.
Aesthetic Appeal: There&#;s a charm to hard gold. It glows with an irresistible sheen, lending your board a touch of allure. It&#;s a beauty that&#;s more than skin deep.
Cons
Thickness: The coat of hard gold is thin. It is but a sheet, leaving your copper bare if worn away.
Selective Coverage: The hard gold finish is not all-encompassing. It chooses its territories wisely, usually connector points. The rest, it leaves bare.
Complex Process: The creation of hard gold is a craft. It requires precision, a careful hand, and time. A complex ballet of chemicals and electrical currents.
Uses Cases
Edge Connectors: Hard gold finds a home at edge connectors. It slides in, forming a bond, a connection that lasts.
Keypads: Keypads, are the medium of man and machine. Hard gold embraces the constant touch, enduring the daily dialogues.
Control Panels: Control panels, are the brain of a device. Hard gold weaves itself into the circuits, creating seamless pathways.
Switches and Sliders: The versatile gold lends its service to switches and sliders, ensuring their operation is smooth and reliable.
8. Immersion Nickel Gold (IMG)
IMG is a surface finish, born from a two-step process. It starts with the deposition of nickel onto the copper surface. Then, a layer of gold follows. This finish aims to protect the copper from oxidation.
Pros
High corrosion resistance, safeguarding your circuit boards.
Good for fine-pitch components.
Cons
Costly, due to the gold involved.
Nickel corrosion might be an issue.
Use cases
Works well for soldering.
Suitable for applications demanding longevity, like in aerospace or medical devices.
9. Directly Plated Copper (DPC)
DPC involves the electrochemical deposition of copper directly onto the surface. This method is a part of the PCB manufacturing process.
Pros
Good for thermal management.
High electrical conductivity.
Cons
Can have poor adhesion with some materials.
Susceptible to corrosion if not protected.
Use cases
Used in high-frequency applications.
Effective in LED lighting systems, due to excellent thermal properties.
10. Electroless Nickel Electroless Palladium (ENEP)
ENEP is a process where nickel is deposited onto a surface, followed by palladium. Unlike other methods, this doesn&#;t involve electricity.
Pros
High resistance to wear and corrosion.
Good for fine-pitch applications.
Cons
More costly than other finishes.
This may be subject to the &#;black pad&#; phenomenon.
Use cases
Ideal for high-reliability applications.
Used in harsh environments like automotive and industrial electronics.
Comparison of Surface Finishes
Surface Finish Type Process Advantages Disadvantages
Hot Air Solder Leveling (HASL-Lead Free)
Uses molten solder and hot air knives.
Inexpensive, widely available, and good for hole plating.
Not suitable for fine-pitch components, can cause uneven surfaces.
Immersion Tin(ISn)
PCB is immersed in a tin bath.
Flat surfaces, good for press-fit pin insertion.
Potential for tin whiskers, sensitive to handling.
Immersion Silver(IAg)
PCB immersed in a silver bath.
Flat surfaces, good solderability.
Sensitive to handling, tarnishing, and limited shelf life.
Electroless Nickel Immersion Gold (ENIG)
Nickel is plated onto the PCB, followed by a layer of immersion gold.
Flat surfaces, good for fine pitch components, long shelf life.
Expensive, potential for black pad syndrome.
Electroless Nickel Electroless Palladium Immersion Gold (ENEPIG)
Nickel is plated onto the PCB, followed by a layer of palladium and then immersion gold.
Excellent solderability and wire bonding capabilities.
Expensive, complex process.
Organic Solderability Preservatives (OSP)
A thin layer of organic material is placed over bare copper.
Inexpensive, flat surfaces.
Limited reworkability, sensitivity to handling, and limited shelf life.
Hard Gold Plating
A hard, durable gold layer is plated onto the PCB.
Durable, excellent conductivity, ideal for mating surfaces.
Expensive, and not suitable for soldering.
Immersion Nickel Gold (IMG)
Similar to ENIG but involves immersion of gold over nickel.
Good solderability, flat surfaces.
Expensive, potential for black pad syndrome.
Directly Plated Copper (DPC)
A layer of copper is plated directly onto the PCB.
Good for signal integrity, suitable for high frequencies.
More complex processes may require special handling.
Electroless Nickel Electroless Palladium (ENEP)
Similar to ENEPIG, but without the final immersion gold layer.
Good solderability and wire bonding capabilities.
Expensive, complex process.
Factors to Consider When Selecting a PCB Surface Finishes
Deciding on a Printed Circuit Board (PCB) surface finish is not to be taken lightly. It&#;s an intricate process. It demands a comprehensive understanding of your specific needs. Also, the environmental factors the PCB will face and the budget for the project. Let&#;s delve into some key considerations that will guide this decision.
1. CostExpense is often the first factor we consider. Remember, the cost isn&#;t solely about the upfront payment for the surface finish. Consider long-term implications too. For instance, HASL is an economical choice. Yet, it&#;s not suitable for high-density or fine-pitch components. ENIG might cost more initially but could save money in the long run by reducing manufacturing defects.
2. Application RequirementsKnowing how your PCB will be used is crucial. This guides the selection of an appropriate finish. For example, a PCB used in a device requiring high-frequency signals could benefit from Directly Plated Copper (DPC). This is due to its excellent signal integrity.
3. Function of the PCBThe function of the PCB is equally important. Is your PCB part of a device that needs strong conductivity? You might consider Hard Gold Plating. This finish boasts excellent conductivity. Yet, it&#;s not suitable for soldering. Always match the finish to the function.
4. EnvironmentConsider the environment where your PCB will operate. An outdoor environment with high humidity might require a robust finish like ENIG. It offers long shelf life and resists corrosion.
5. Shelf LifeIf your PCBs are stored for extended periods, surface finish matters. Some finishes, like OSP, have a limited shelf life. Conversely, ENIG offers a longer shelf life.
6. Reliability RequirementsIn applications where reliability is paramount, the choice of surface finish is vital. For high-reliability applications, consider ENEPIG or ENEP. These finishes offer excellent solderability and wire bonding capabilities.
7. Working with Your PCB ManufacturerFinally, involve your PCB manufacturer in the decision-making process. They have the expertise to help navigate these complex considerations. MorePCB as one professional PCB manufacturer is able to supply you with correct suggestions for all your PCBs.
Conclusion
When choosing a surface finish for your PCB, it is crucial to consider the available options while taking into account performance requirements and material costs. Let&#;s consider an example: if cost is a primary concern and RoHS compliance is not required, Tin-Lead HASL might initially seem like a good choice. However, it&#;s important to note that this finish is not suitable for RoHS-compliant products. In that case, you could consider lead-free HASL. However, if your design includes fine-pitch components, HASL-LF may not provide a perfectly flat surface.
In situations where both RoHS compliance and fine pitch components are involved, you&#;ll need to opt for a flat, lead-free finish like Immersion Silver or ENIG. Keep in mind that using these finishes may require the use of more expensive high-temperature laminate.
If you&#;re unsure about the most appropriate surface finishes for your project, it&#;s advisable to consult with MorePCB before making a final decision. Our expertise will ensure that the chosen combination of surface finish and material yields a cost-effective design with optimal performance.
Ready to bring your PCB designs to life?
Contact MorePCB today and experience top-quality manufacturing,
quick turnaround times, and exceptional customer service.
For more information, please visit multilayer pcb design tips.
Contact us and request a quote and start your next project!